More feedback – Assignment One prep’

I am in somewhat of a quandary. Should I continue to ask for more feedback, using the burgeoning network I have and am developing or consider this a staging post, collect my thoughts, re-edit and submit the BoW? I suspect both, until I have less of an itch  about how well I think I have done in expressing what I feel about the narrative.

johnumneyfeedback

Fiona has provided me with her feedback – above in full – the assignment doesn’t say to comment on the feedback, I suspect that is implied. I imagine that the benefit of the commentary is roughly halved if I don’t engage with it. So here goes:

There are no vehicles as a distance learner for critique’s, so therefore no rules of engagement, no ‘house-practice’ in how work is discussed and received. And whilst I have known Fiona for a year or so, we haven’t worked together on anything like this and her first sentence makes it very clear how she has approached this work. This might be especially important in this case because, as she she says: “This is a very personal work and therefor by this very nature impossible to critic with out fear of a critic towards the artist himself. They are so intertwined.” 

When we met at the “Uncertain States” exhibition recently I had some of the work with me – a short edit – so she had a very good sense of how the work, as a whole, might look. The Pdf that I sent re-presented the work which, as she states: “…something else happened that I am not sure you intended. I saw diptychs.”. So, another lesson learned, that despite me effort to acquaint Fiona with the physical representation of the work it (the work) became something else in the transition.

Again, when we met, Fiona had suggested that the title of the work didn’t work well for her; she said then “…. I like that less as I feel you are telling me something that you dont trust I will discover.” I’m still unsure about the title of the work, my thoughts are to keep it as is for the time being and rest on it. The title was talked about in Glasgow favourably so I have the inclination to keep it.

The text that Fiona thinks is a little verbose – with “childhood” in it three times is a direct quote from Boltanski, which I think accurate sums up what I feel, and reflecting on the various texts – which overall Fiona, and the artists in Glasgow agree are very strong (perhaps too strong?) – I’m wondering whether I should use my own words. My tutor’s advice was to be consistent with the texts when I made my last edit, so this might confirm her thoughts, but I am conflicted about using someone else’s words, despite agreeing with the sentiment.

Fiona’s last paragraph was very warming and expresses some of my hopes for the work very well and her advice is something I shall consider very carefully before presenting the BoW for assessment.

However something very important (to me) in Fiona’s text was this: “I personally don’t feel you are looking for him but for yourself.” Maybe that was obvious all along.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “More feedback – Assignment One prep’

  1. How much is enough feedback? I’m asking that because it’s as if there’s something in all the feedback that is missing for you.
    Regarding the text. It became more real for me when you did use some of your own words. If you use words from others then a distance is created. It might be that you want/need to retain a little distance though.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’ve always been ‘needy’ Catherine 😉 I think you are right about the ‘real’ when the words are mine. I think I’ll re-write the Boltanski quote and try and find a way to attribute the sentiment. Getting close to submission now!

      Like

  2. Catherine has a good point here. I found myself going round in circles when I got conflicting feedback. My sense on the text is that using your own words, in some cases reflecting the sentiments of others that you empathise with, might be the way to go. Keeping the texts short yet retaining an openness to interpretation is also an approach that I would favour…. your decision in the end John. You are very close to reaching a conclusion… look forward to seeing the final version.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Good point Keith, but I think I can sense what the work needs. I’ve been reflecting on the final outcome and wonder if there will be one, whether it continues…. Safe journey.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s